This QB ranking list from Clayton is basically silly. He divides QB’s into 3 categories: elite, Chad Pennington, and hit-or-miss. So who’s “elite,” you ask?
Pretty much half the starting QB’s in the league. That’s all.
The word “elite” refers to the highest achievers of a group. You can’t throw half of the group into a category and call it “the elite.” I mean, a category that has Tom Brady, Drew Brees and Peyton Manning also has Tony Romo and Donovan McNabb? Really?
He needs a list-making lesson from Bill Simmons.